15 Creatively Gory Moments in the Sin City Comics and Graphic Novels

Rhune Kincaid
Updated May 3, 2024 15 items
Ranked By
385 votes
104 voters
Voting Rules

Vote up the most unique kills and punishments in the Sin City comics.

If you walk down the wrong (or right, depending on how you look at it) back alley in Sin City, you can find anything. A dismembered body part. A few gallons of blood and guts. Frank Miller's signature series isn't just a grandiose homage to the film noir and hard-boiled crime genres, it's also one of the most creatively gory comics of all time. You're probably thinking, "So what? There are so many gory Frank Miller comics." And it's true; the guy inks his pages like Jackson Pollock painting with blood. But it's the imagination in the most violent Sin City scenes that truly sets the series apart.

Released between 1991 and 1992, the first thirteen installments, The Hard Goodbye, kicked off years of gory Sin City comics and violent graphic novels. From exploding heads to dismembered "members," these are the goriest moments in Sin City comic books.

  • 1
    39 VOTES

    Marv Feeds Kevin to His Own Pet Wolf

    Marv Feeds Kevin to His Own Pet Wolf
    Photo: Dark Horse

    For the penultimate murder in his Sin City-wide rampage, Marv catches Kevin the Cannibal with a pair of handcuffs. Then he semi-surgically removes Kevin's limbs and uses them as appetizers for Kevin's man-eating wolf. Kevin's spookily silent quadriplegic corpus is the main course. It's gory, but thanks to medical tubing and Marv's mitts, it's relatively tidy.

    39 votes
  • 2
    30 VOTES

    Lucille's Hand

    Lucille's Hand
    Photo: Dark Horse

    When Marv gets locked up with Lucille in Kevin's dungeon, she keeps her cool for a moment before revealing that her hand is now a stump (courtesy of cannibalism). Wrapped in bandages, the goriest aspects come through her description of being made to watch Kevin suck the meat off of her fingers.

    30 votes
  • 3
    31 VOTES

    Kevin's Wall of Decapitated Prostitute Heads

    Kevin's Wall of Decapitated Prostitute Heads
    Photo: Dark Horse

    Kevin decorates his man cave with the faces of beautiful women, which is totally normal, except his man cave is a dungeon, and the faces are more like whole heads that aren't attached to bodies anymore because Kevin ate said bodies. So really, it's not normal at all.

    31 votes
  • 4
    21 VOTES

    That Yellow Bastard's Little Yellow Bastard Gets Torn Off

    That Yellow Bastard's Little Yellow Bastard Gets Torn Off
    Photo: Dark Horse

    Having failed to fully castrate Rourke Jr. on his first attempt, Hartigan finishes the job eight years later. Not only does Hartigan remove the younger Rourke's genitals with his bare hands, he also smashes his yellowed head into a pulpy soup

    21 votes
  • 5
    15 VOTES

    Miho Roller-Boots a Dude's Head Off

    Miho Roller-Boots a Dude's Head Off
    Photo: Dark Horse

    After toying with Vinnie for far too long (at least according to Dwight), Miho uses her roller skates to deliver what is probably the most awesome decapitation in all of Sin City (and there are a lot). Roller skates and roller-booting are extremely under-utilized in non-Frank Miller comics.

    15 votes
  • 6
    20 VOTES

    Hartigan Blasts Off Roark Jr.'s Testicles

    Hartigan Blasts Off Roark Jr.'s Testicles
    Photo: Dark Horse

    Hartigan blasts off (or more accurately, tries to blast off) Roark Jr.'s testicles in their first battle over skinny little Nancy Callahan. He also blows off Junior's hand. Unfortunately for all the non-Roarks in Basin City, his parts grow back yellower and nastier than ever.

    20 votes
  • 7
    18 VOTES

    Miho Punctures Some Craniums

    Miho Punctures Some Craniums
    Photo: Dark Horse

    In between the indignities she inflicts on Jackie Boy, deadly little Miho finds time to jab her katanas through the brains of three of his compatriots before decapitating a fourth. 

    18 votes
  • 8
    15 VOTES

    Frat Boys Burn the Homeless

    Frat Boys Burn the Homeless
    Photo: Dark Horse

    Once his head clears a little, Marv remembers that the inciting incident in "Just Another Saturday Night" was some frat boys burning the homeless. That's pretty horrific, even for frat boys.

    15 votes
  • 9
    22 VOTES

    Jackie Boy's Many Gruesome Humiliations

    Jackie Boy's Many Gruesome Humiliations
    Photo: Dark Horse

    The "god damn hero cop" suffers a comical gore fest at the hands of Miho. First, his hand is removed by her throwing star. He subsequently falls on said star, lodging it in his buttcheek. Then she blocks the barrel of his gun, it backfires, and the shrapnel flies straight into his brain. Finally, Miho cuts his head off with a katana, but it doesn't come off clean. Says Dwight: "She makes a Pez dispenser out of him."

    22 votes
  • 10
    23 VOTES

    Whatever Marv Did to Cardinal Roark

    Whatever Marv Did to Cardinal Roark
    Photo: Dark Horse

    Marv's narration doesn't say what he does to Cardinal Roark, but he does mention that it's very, very bad. We get to see one panel where Marv's face is drenched in blood, and the Cardinal's fingers are pointed in the wrong directions. It safe to say Marv did more than just pop the corrupt clergyman's knuckles.

    23 votes
  • 11
    9 VOTES

    Delia Sticks a Stilleto Through the Wrong Guy's Eye

    Delia Sticks a Stilleto Through the Wrong Guy's Eye
    Photo: Dark Horse

    Delia is in the middle of choking her target while having sex with him when she realizes she's got the wrong man. At that point, he already knows too much, so she stabs his brain with a projectile high heel to the eye. The poor guy's wife gets killed too. Delia is mean.

    9 votes
  • 12
    18 VOTES

    Dwight's Jackie Boy Eyeball Bomb

    Dwight's Jackie Boy Eyeball Bomb
    Photo: Dark Horse

    Have you ever wondered what it would look like if you put a grenade in someone's head and then threw that your enemies? Wonder no more! Frank Miller has drawn that for you in the conclusion to The Big Fat Kill.

    18 votes
  • 13
    18 VOTES

    Manute Throws Dwight Out a Window

    Manute Throws Dwight Out a Window
    Photo: Dark Horse

    When Manute catches Dwight with Ava, Dwight gets sent through a second- or third-story window in his birthday suit. That leads to a lot of glass shards, a lot of cuts, and one bloody mess on the pavement.

    18 votes
  • 14
    9 VOTES

    Damien Lord's Pulpy Demise

    Damien Lord's Pulpy Demise
    Photo: Dark Horse

    When Dwight's efforts to teach Damien Lord a lesson go too far, it ends in an accidental death. But it's not just any accidental death. Damian dies from too many fists to the face. That's a rare cause of death for millionaires.

    9 votes
  • 15
    8 VOTES

    Wallace Snipes a Sniper with a Pistol

    Wallace Snipes a Sniper with a Pistol
    Photo: Dark Horse

    It turns out that Wallace's mysterious Navy SEAL skills include firing a bullet through the scope, eye socket, and brain of an enemy sniper. For bonus weirdness, these particular splattered brains belong to a sniper who happens to be wearing nothing but his business socks.

    8 votes